top of page

The Question in the Car: How Parents and Coaches Build the Climate Your Athlete Plays In

Nov 9
4 min read

The game ended twenty minutes ago. The car is quiet. Your athlete is looking out the window, and you can feel the first sentence building.


"Did you win?"

"What happened on that last at-bat?"

"Why did Coach pull you?"


That first sentence matters more than most of us think. Kids learn what we value from what we ask about first, not from the speech we give at the start of the season. Over a few hundred rides home, those first sentences add up to something researchers have a name for: the climate your athlete plays in.


What "climate" means, in plain words


Sport psychologists talk about two kinds of climate around a young athlete.


A mastery climate rewards effort, learning and improvement. The questions sound like "What did you work on?" and "What got better today?"


A performance climate rewards winning, beating others and the scoreboard. The questions sound like "Did you win?" and "How many did you score?"


Most homes and most teams have some of both. Caring about winning isn't wrong. Competitors want to win, and they should. The question is which message your athlete hears most often, and whether the adults around them are sending the same one.


A father and his young wrestler son talk at a dinner table at night.

What a new study found


This summer, researchers published a study of 347 young athletes, ages 9 to 15, in the journal Psychology of Sport and Exercise (Fuller and colleagues, 2026). What made it unusual is that they asked kids about their parent and their coach at the same time, instead of studying one adult in isolation.


The healthiest pattern


When both the parent and the coach mostly emphasized improvement, athletes reported more enjoyment and less stress. The group where both adults also played down the scoreboard had the lowest stress of all.


The hardest pattern


When both adults leaned on results, stress went up and enjoyment went down.


The surprising one


When neither adult sent a clear message either way, enjoyment was the lowest of any group, and stress was as high as in the results-focused groups. Mixed or absent signals didn't feel neutral to kids. They felt confusing.


One more detail: in this sample, parents and coaches mostly sent the same message. The climate gets built at home and on the bench together.


"This program is built on internal joy, not external applause." — Lincoln Riley, USC head coach, after his team beat No. 2 Ohio State, one week after a 24–7 loss

That line was about a college football team. It describes your passenger seat just as well.


What the study does not say


This is a one-time survey, so it shows a pattern, not proof. It doesn't prove that a parent's questions cause a child's stress. Kids who are already stressed may simply notice more pressure around them. It also doesn't say winning is bad: athletes who heard both "get better" and "go win" still enjoyed their sport. They also carried more stress.


And there's an honest limit worth naming. A separate 2026 study (Moulds and colleagues, Frontiers in Psychology) trained youth swim coaches for twelve weeks to build a better climate. Swimmers did notice a change, but it was very small. Knowing about climate is easy. Changing it takes daily reps.


That's the real takeaway for parents. One good conversation won't change much. The question you ask every week will.


A young basketball player closes her eyes and breathes at the free throw line.

Five questions to ask after the game


Pick one. Use it every ride for two weeks. Then listen, even if you get one-word answers at first.


1. "What was the most fun part of today?"


It reminds them why they play, and tells them you care about them, not the box score.


2. "What's one thing you got better at?"


It trains their brain to look for evidence of growth, even on an 0-for-3 night.


3. "Where did you feel strongest?"


It gives them something true and positive to hold onto after a loss.


4. "Want to talk about it now, or after we eat?"


After a hard game, it gives them control over the one thing they can control right then.


5. "What did you notice from the bench?"


When they didn't play, it turns them back into a player instead of a spectator.


Two questions to retire for a while


"Did you win?" You already know, and so do they. Leading with it tells them the scoreboard is what you were watching.


"What happened on that last play?" The replay can wait. In the car, it usually sounds like a grade, even when you mean it as help.


None of this means you never talk about the game. It means you let them bring it up first, and you follow their lead.


A football coach leans in to speak to his kicker on the sideline at night.

What coaches can do


Coaches set the other half of the climate. Athletes copy what a coach does after a mistake far more than what a coach says about mistakes. Choose two or three words for after an error ("next ball," "eyes up, go again") and say them the same way every time. Then share those words with your families. When the bench and the bleachers use the same language, the climate gets clearer for the kid in the middle.


Where to start


If you want help with exactly these conversations, I'm teaching The Next Play, a live, online workshop for sports parents, on Thursday, November 19, from 7:00 to 8:15 PM Central. We'll work on what to say after the hard games, and how to help your athlete reset when one mistake starts to follow them all weekend. Save your family's spot at coachronmpm.com/workshop.


The scoreboard will always be loud. Your athlete doesn't need you to repeat it. They need one adult who asks about the part they control.


Winning Starts Within.


Coach Ron Schmittling is a mental performance coach in Chesterfield, Missouri. He spent more than a decade coaching elite athletes and works with athletes, parents, coaches and teams on the mental side of competition. Mental performance coaching is skills training, not therapy; if your athlete is struggling with something bigger than sport, a licensed professional is the right first call.


Comments


bottom of page