top of page

After the Mistake: What Your Athlete Says to Herself Next, and Why It Matters

6 days ago
4 min read

She boots the ground ball in the fifth inning. The runner is safe. The crowd groans. And then comes the part nobody in the bleachers can see: the walk back to her spot at shortstop.


That walk takes about six seconds. What she says to herself during it decides a lot about the next ball hit her way.


Six seconds, good or bad


Earlier this month, UCLA quarterback Ty Dieffenbach described exactly how he handles that window. He had started the season as the backup. Then he was thrown into the starting job and kept winning.


"Next-play mentality. Six seconds every play and then we move on, good or bad." — Ty Dieffenbach, UCLA

He followed that up with back-to-back 75-yard touchdown passes.


Notice what he did not say. He did not say he never makes mistakes. He said every play, good or bad, gets six seconds. Then it is over.


Most young athletes do the opposite. The mistake ends, but they don't. One error becomes two. Two becomes an inning. By the time the inning ends, the problem is no longer the ground ball. The problem is the sentence she has been repeating since.


A young shortstop adjusts his glove as he walks back to his position under the lights.

What the new research says


A study published in Frontiers in Psychology on Oct 29, 2026 looked at this exact moment from a different angle. Researchers asked adult athletes how often they had choked under pressure and how they had felt afterward.


The finding


Over the previous three months, athletes who choked more often also reported feeling worse. But that link mostly disappeared in one group: the athletes who treated themselves with more kindness after a mistake. For athletes low in self-compassion, the link was strong. For athletes high in it, it was close to nothing.


The limits


It is one study. It is exploratory, the effect was small, and it studied adults, not kids. It does not prove that being kinder to yourself causes anything. I hold it loosely.


But it lines up with what I've watched for years from the dugout. The athletes who keep getting better are not the ones who never miss. They are the ones who don't pile on after they miss.


Why a handout isn't enough


A separate study of NCAA athletes (Kuchar, Neff and Mosewich, 2023) tried a short, six-session course to build that kinder voice. The skill moved. Coaches even rated performance higher. But the course alone did not change the bigger outcomes.


That is the honest picture. Knowing the skill and owning it are two different things. Owning it takes reps, week after week, the same way a swing does.


A young volleyball player in a ready stance on the back line, eyes on the server.

Kind is not soft


Some parents hear "be kind to yourself" and worry their athlete will stop caring. That's not what this is.


You're allowed to care. Mental performance does not mean walking off the field after playing terribly and saying everything's awesome. The heat in your face after an error means you care. I don't want athletes to care less.


What I want is for the caring to point forward. There is a massive difference between "what happened" and "what's wrong with me." One gives you information. The other gives you shame. Information helps you field the next ball. Shame makes you hope it doesn't come to you.


That is why I teach athletes a short in-game reset. I call it the Green Ball Reset: release it, breathe, refocus on your spot and a line you actually believe, then go. It takes about ten seconds. Here is one rep to try tonight: the next time a mistake happens in practice, run it once, on purpose, before the next ball. That's it.


The full version, built around what your athlete actually says to herself, is what we work on together.


What the walk back can sound like


Here is the same error, two different walks.


Walk one: "Here we go again. Of course. Every single time." That sentence turns one ground ball into an identity. By the next pitch, she's playing not to make another one.


Walk two: "That one stung. Glove down earlier. Next ball." Same error. Same embarrassment. But now she has information instead of a verdict, and her eyes are already back on the hitter.


It works the same way in every sport. The volleyball passer who shanks a serve. The goalie who lets one in at the near post. The hitter who chases a pitch in the dirt. The first sentence after the miss decides whether the next play gets her full attention.


Nobody gets to walk two by being told to "shake it off." They get there by practicing it when it's calm, so it's there when it isn't.


A parent watches quietly from the bleachers at dusk, the field glowing in the distance.

Where parents come in


Here is the part parents rarely hear. That inner voice gets built over years: by coaches, by teammates, and by us.


Kids learn what we value from what we ask about first. If the first question in the car is about the error, the error is what they carry home. Under pressure, our words become their words.


A national survey from the Aspen Institute this year found that kids who quit sports were more than twice as likely as current players to say they felt pressured to play, 21% versus 9%. The top thing former players disliked was the feeling of "I'm not good enough."


None of us mean to add to that. But we can stop feeding it.


Three things to try after the next tough game


Give it time. Let the first ten minutes of the ride be quiet if that's what your athlete needs.


Ask about something other than the score. "What was the most fun part of today?" opens a different door than "What happened on that grounder?"


Name the miss once, then move on. "That one stung. What do you want to work on this week?" Then let it go.


The next play starts in your athlete's head


Every athlete makes the error. The difference is the six seconds after it, and the voice that fills them.


If you want to know what your athlete says to herself when it counts, and what to do about it, that is exactly what the Mental Performance Diagnostic is built to find. We look at what takes over first under pressure, and we build the plan from there.


Book the Mental Performance Diagnostic: coachronmpm.com/diagnostic

Comments


bottom of page